Milk & Krunchies Gourmet Rice Crispy Treat Taste Test

Kookies n' Kreme rice crispy treat

Milk & Krunchies' Kookies n' Kreme rice crispy treat

I don’t know how but I ended up with a cinnamon doughnut from Huckleberry, Schat’s cinnamon pecan loaf and salted caramels at my desk. I blame the booze fast which has only served to aggravate my sweet tooth. Always snacking now. So you can imagine how conflicted I was when Milk & Krunchies sent over a box of four of its gourmet rice crispy flavors for me to check out.

As much as I wanted to, there was just no way I could eat all those and at the same time I didn’t want them to go to waste. So I enlisted the help of four of my co-workers. Co-workers who I knew had refined palates. Well, OK, they just like sweet treats, too.

I’d just have them taste each treat and let me know their impressions.

At 3pm, the midday snacking hour, we met up in the company kitchen area and sampled the following M&K flavors:

  • DJ AM?s Toffee Mix: Toffee bits and milk chocolate, which was DJ AM’s favorite flavor and incited his business partnership with M&K founders Melissa and Kathleen
  • Kookies n? Kreme: Chunks of Oreo cookies and drizzled with dark and white chocolate
  • Peanut Buttercup: Peanut butter and milk chocolate
  • PB&J Sandwich: Strawberry jelly and peanut butter

First Impressions

Four Milk & Krunchies flavors.

Four Milk & Krunchies flavors.

Everyone was pretty lukewarm about the peanut butter flavored treats, which we agreed just didn’t have a

strong-enough peanut butter presence. “It needs more peanut butter to balance it,” said one taste

tester of the PB&J Sandwich. The peanut was so mild that some of us even questioned if there was any PB in the ingredients.

The girls thought the Peanut Buttercup looked pretty what with its drizzling of peanut butter on the chocolate layer; looking like a Tiger Butter bar. “This one kicks ass,” said one taster of the treat. All agreed this one was not as dry as the PB&J and it had a tiny bit more peanut butter flavor.

Of the Kookies n’ Kreme, there were mixed opinions. Some thought it was a nice rice crispy treat with a little something different.  While others thought the flavors were “way too subtle.” “I just taste the white icing.”

The DJ AM toffee treat kicked off a brief conversation about DJ AM’s sudden death last year, and then we moved on to the treat. “It has a much stronger taste. You can taste the toffee.” “This is the one most true to its name.” “It’s sweeter, too.” “It’s the first one I can see sitting in a cafe and enjoying with coffee.”

Final Verdict

It’s no surprise that DJ AM’s Toffee Mix was the resounding favorite. While we all appreciated that none of the treats were uber sweet, we ended up liking the sweetest of the bunch. Our least favorite of the four was the

DJ AM's Toffee Mix

DJ AM's Toffee Mix

PB&J which didn’t really impress us at all. “Why would I buy this one when I can just make something like it at home?” one taster asked. While the toffee treat proved exceptional. Definitely not as easy to duplicate in your own kitchen.

Regarding pricing, on the M&K site, they come out to about $18 for a box of six. All but one person said they liked the price of the treat which is basically $3 each. The dissenting voice reasoned, “That’s a little pricey for an RK bar, even with the extra flavors. I’d pay $2 or maybe $2.50 tops.”  Apart from the site, you can also buy them at Joan’s on Third, Vincente Foods and Nordstrom Espresso Bars.

BTW,  as a memorial for DJ AM, whose birthday would have been March 30, Milk & Krunchies is selling a special gift box containing two toffee treats for $10. All proceeds will be donated to the DJ AM Memorial Fund which helps organizations and projects addressing addiction and recovery.

Twitter: @milknkrunchies

4 Responses to Milk & Krunchies Gourmet Rice Crispy Treat Taste Test
  1. Elise
    March 24, 2010 | 7:22 pm

    Oh my God, I want to go buy a hundred different ingredients and make Rice Krispies Treats all night. Heath Bars! Coconut macadamia nut crunch! S’mores!

  2. Caroline on Crack
    March 24, 2010 | 10:21 pm

    Ooh! In that case have a Rice Krispies Treats party and invite me over.

  3. Nastassia
    March 24, 2010 | 10:37 pm

    I love milk n’ krunchies. When they were first starting out the sent their products to Joan’s and we’ve carried them ever since! The new cookies and cream is one of my faves 🙂

  4. Caroline on Crack
    March 24, 2010 | 10:46 pm

    Yeah, and if Joan’s carries it, you know it’s some good stuff. I really loved the DJ AM one.

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Trackback URL https://carolineoncrack.com/2010/03/24/milk-krunchies-gourmet-rice-crispy-treat-taste-test/trackback/